wicked.eng |
Group: Members Joined: 06th Jul, 2007 Topic: 1 Post: 3 Age:
30
|
|
Posted on:6th Jul 2007, 3:00am |
|
|
Masturbation: Why Prohibited In Islam?
AOA to all the members and respected Dr's....im an Engineer and dun kno much abt this doctor stuff but i had a question in mind regardind Khna_80 reply about "Mustarbation has no Effect on health"...well according my knowledge Mustarbation is strictly prohibited in Islam so as far as i kno any thing which is prohibited in islam has Disadvantages to human health..there is nothing in islam tht is prohibited and has no effect on human health tht im sure abt....so all of u Doctor hazraat says it has no effect on the health then y is it prohibited in islam?? isnt it a Contradicting Answer??...i kno tht it has some Psychological effects on ppl....plz can u clear me out on this one...Thnks
|
khoobsurat |
Group: Members Joined: 06th Jul, 2007 Topic: 32 Post: 326 Age:
27
|
|
Posted on:6th Jul 2007, 2:36pm |
|
|
re: Masturbation allah ne har cheez ka ek nizaam banaya hay. agar sab boys masturbation kar ke apni sex tension khatam kar lege to shadi kon karega aur medical point of view chahe kuch bhi ho, agar koi cheez islam main mana hay to woh karne ke liye aap medical se opinion to nahi lenge naa. aap medical ki baat bhool jaen, jo kaam islam main mana hay woh kabhi naa karen. baaqi aap ki marzi hay. ham koi police to nahi jo masturbation karne wale ko jail main daal saken. |
My Reply |
Group: Members Joined: 19th Sep, 2010 Topic: 2 Post: 2015 Age:
34
|
|
Posted on:6th Jul 2007, 6:43pm |
|
|
re: wicked.eng
1. agar koi cheez islam mai mana hai tu phir woh kam nahi karna chahia, chahe medically allow ho ya na ho.
2. agar masturbation islam mai allow nahi hai tu mai bhi yahi kahoo ga keh masturbation nahi karna chahia chahe yeh medically allow hi kio na ho.
3. lekin kia waqai masturbation islam mai mana hai. agar mana hai tu barai meharbani Quran aur Hadees ke reference se batai keh masturbation islam mai mana hai. sirf zubani kahne se keh mai ne suna hai keh islam mai mana hai acceptable logic nahi hai. reference zaroori hai.
4. For more information read: Masturbation And Islam.
5. masturbation aik bad habit hai. lekin medically koi nuqsan nahi hai. medical science aise mardo ko masturbation ka mashwarah deta hai jo apni bivi se door doosre city ya country mai job kar rahe ho.
|
nono |
Group: Members Joined: 21st Jun, 2007 Topic: 9 Post: 33 Age:
39
|
|
Posted on:7th Jul 2007, 7:03am |
|
|
RE:Mr Reply Dear Sir,
May nay darul uloom korangi say iss maslay kay baray may malom kiya to un ho no kaha kay iss kay baray may do ahadees batlain jin ka mafhoom likh raha hon
1- iss amal ka karnay wala rooz qayamat iss hal may hoga kay iss kay hath may "HAMAL" hoga , yani sab say samnay ibrat hoga.
2- iss amal kay karnay walay par hadees may lanat aaee hay.
yeh hadees mishkat shareef may hain.
Mufti asghar ali rabbani cell number:0300-9218809 Darul uloom korangi karachi |
My Reply |
Group: Members Joined: 19th Sep, 2010 Topic: 2 Post: 2015 Age:
34
|
|
Posted on:7th Jul 2007, 8:02am |
|
|
re: nono
1. ap ne bahut hi maloomati bat kahi hai. ap ka bahut bahut shukria.
2. molvio ke apas mai ikhtelafat hote hai jis ki wajah se kai maslak ban gai hai. lehaza ham kisi molvi ke fatwe ko drust nahi mante.
3. albatta Quarn aur Hadeth ko mante hai.
4. lehaza ap se darkhast hai keh hadeth ka mafhoom likhne ki bajai asal tarjama likhe, hadeth ki book ka name aur page number bhi likhe.
5. ham moderator se bhi darkhast karte hai keh agar nono ne hadith ka tarjama, hadeth book name aur page number mention kare to wo bhi apni website ke article Masturbation And Islam. ko edit kar le.
|
IT_Enginer |
Group: Members Joined: 06th Jul, 2007 Topic: 1 Post: 3 Age:
34
|
|
Posted on:7th Jul 2007, 10:49am |
|
|
Affects Of Masterbation
"THIS SUBJECT IS NOT TO SCARE THE PPL WHO MASTERBATE BUT TO INFORM ITS CONSIQUENCES PHSYCOLOGICALLY AND MEDICALLY" Extreme Masterbation leads to desctruction of personality, Creats extreme level self conciousness and also some medical illness can ocuur like "VARICOCELS" Dialated Veins in the testicle, which creats infertality, testicles lose its original position and hangs in the scrotum bag. plus extreme masterbation for prolonged periods can cause thombos, which mean that blood flow from upper portion like head and arms and brain specially becomes low and most cases can cause death if a person is masterbator and chain smoker. Extreme Masterbation also destroys reflexs and can cause damage to neurological Structre. Cases have been found in the US that ppl have died doing masterbation at extreme levels. THERE IS a Medical Term "ANDROLOGY". There Are doctors who specifically deal with this area of experteise. which is about sexual disturbances and there side effects. Although I am not Doctor But this is what i found exploring medical journols and medical web site. Plus further help please visit -- You will also find your answers there. Thanks Moderator Note: Medically the above information is 100% wrong.
|
My Reply |
Group: Members Joined: 19th Sep, 2010 Topic: 2 Post: 2015 Age:
34
|
|
Posted on:7th Jul 2007, 2:18pm |
|
|
re: IT_Enginer 1. ap aik medical doctor nahi hai. jab keh mai aik MBBS doctor hoo aur MBBS doctor ki haisiat se kah raha hoo keh ap ne masturbation ko jo bhi nuqsanat batai hai woh 100% ghalat hai.
2. jab ap MBBS doctor nahi hai tu yaha par forum ke members ko fazool aur ghalat information de kar kio confuse kar rahe hai.
3. Yeh aik medical forum hai. yaha medical ki batai sirf doctors ko karne de.
4. yeh website ap jaise logo ke lia banai gai hai jo jali doctors aur jali hakeemo ki taraf se di gai information ki wajah se na sirf khood confuse hai balkeh doosro ko bhi confuse kar rahe hai.
|
wicked.eng |
Group: Members Joined: 06th Jul, 2007 Topic: 1 Post: 3 Age:
30
|
|
Posted on:8th Jul 2007, 9:17pm |
|
|
re: My Reply @ MY Reply sir IT_Engineer is not a doc as he told but he has done research abt tht and hes giving tht info abt it...may b he has also got tht info frm some medical journel as he say...but he didnt say im a doc or anuthing like tht so y r u critizing him just say tht info u provide is not correct v r not here to fight may b sumthing tht u didnt kno and any other person get to kno abt dosent means tht hes wrong u shud also do sum research abt it.....i kno this medical field is v vast so i dun think tht u shud immidieatly jump to conclusions and yes there is an authenticated hadith abt masturbation Qouting "Laanat hay un logooun per jo apnay hath say apni taakat ko zaya kartay hain"...and another hadith Qouting "un loogoun kay haat mein hamal thehray ga qayamat walay din"...ill provide u the refrence in my next Post inshallah and tht means it has Bad effects on ur health thts y it is stricktly prohibited thts wht i understand....im not saying tht ur wrong or any other doc is wrong but i believe ISlam can not b wrong or an Authenticated hadith can not b wrong...may allah bless us all...
Regards
Naveed |
nalasra |
Group: Members Joined: 07th Apr, 2007 Topic: 9 Post: 25 Age:
34
|
|
Posted on:9th Jul 2007, 8:15am |
|
|
 Wicked Engineer Sb,
Meree Knowledge to itnee naheen hei laiken pher bhee koshish kerta hoon aap ka jawab dene kee, kia aap ke kahayl mein sex kerne ka koi adverse effect hotra hei kia, laiken Islam ne Shadee se pehle sex kerne ko mana kiahei hei Sex kerne ka bhee koi adverse effet naheen hei health per, to ab Islam ne ye kyon maan kia hei, is baare mein mujhe batadein, isee atrah zeroree naheen hei ke kisee cheez ka adverse effect aap ko laazmee pata hona chaye to tub hee wo Islam mein mana hogee. Islam mein Music bhee mana hei, interest lena bhee mana hei, laiken is ke bawajood bank saare interest lete hein is baare mein aap ka kia khayal hie.
Khan_80 is requested to give her comment |
nono |
Group: Members Joined: 21st Jun, 2007 Topic: 9 Post: 33 Age:
39
|
|
Posted on:9th Jul 2007, 10:39am |
|
|
RE:Mr Reply Dear Sir,
Masalik ko chor dain jab hadees kay Alfaz yeh hon
"Jo yeh amal karay iss par lanat hay "
To kaya iss ko haram kay zamray may nahi laingay ,fiqqa ka asool hay kay jiss cheez par lanat aae ho woh haram hay.
Jasay quran kareem may hay "jhoton par khuda key lanat"
ab jhott gunhee kabira hay lekin phir bhi log kar tay hain , kaya ham har iss kam ko jiss ko logon kee baree tadad karay sahi kahaingay , aur jahan tak medical point of view key bat hay to woh to aksar change hotay rahtay hain.\
kabhi medical science kahti hay Tea anti cancer hay , kabhi kahti hay kay cancer ka sabab hay. Man iss leyee aap ko mufti sahab ka number diya hay yeh Darul uloom kay naiab mufti ho mazeed tasshfi aap kar saktay hain, aur yeh define karain kay aap ko kiss qissam ka hawaal chaheyee,
kaya sharyat may baloghat kay foran bad shadi ka hukom nahi hay. ya yeh bhi worn hay.?
|
wicked.eng |
Group: Members Joined: 06th Jul, 2007 Topic: 1 Post: 3 Age:
30
|
|
Posted on:9th Jul 2007, 1:09pm |
|
|
RE : nalasra MR/MS Nalasra lagta hay waqai app kay pass koi knowledge nai hay...app nay nahait hi ahmakaana baat ki hay...app ka shayad hadees kay baray mein bohoot kam knowledge hay..agar app sahi bukhari ko utha kar dekhain tu aik hadeeds hay which Prophet S.W says " Too much SEX will make the body sick"..plzz go and learn some knowledge... masla ye hay na kay hum logounay nay apnay deen ko choor diya hay is liye itni complications mein partay hain..MR nalasra app nay kaha hay Intrest lainay say koi nuksaan nai hota aur islam mein mana kiun hay...tu sir jahalat ki intehaa hoti hay koi..har cheez ka effect health per hi hona zaroori nai hay intrest ki jo baat app nay ki us say muaashray mein jo tabahi phel rahi hay us ka app ko andaza hay...mera point tha kay agar masterbation islam mein haram hay tu doc kiun kehtay hain is ka koi side effect nai?? mera question ye tha ab app is subject ko hata kar doosri jaga kiun ghseet rahay ho tht does not prove ur point...so try and focus on the subject plz.....MY dear nalasra musik ki jo app nay baat ki tu shayad app nay kabi researchs nahi parhin chalain mein app ko bata daita houn kay ye jo non muslims hain na inhi logoun nay ye researchs ki hain aur musik kay baray mein ye loog b kehtay hain kay is say insaan ka mind materialistic ho jata hay sirf dunyavii....Ab app pe depend karta hay kay app wo karo ya na karoo...app karna chahtay ho karoo koi rookay ga nai but atlest dont give these lame excuses tht islam is this and islam is tht first u shud know wht islam is and wht it sayz..
Regards
Naveed |
My Reply |
Group: Members Joined: 19th Sep, 2010 Topic: 2 Post: 2015 Age:
34
|
|
Posted on:9th Jul 2007, 4:42pm |
|
|
re: nono thanks for giving hadeth on masturbation. Please mention the name of hadeth book and serial numbar of hadeth or page number of that hadeth book. I want ro read myself that hadeth.
|
inam_pk |
Group: Members Joined: 15th Jun, 2007 Topic: 2 Post: 8 Age:
33
|
|
Posted on:12th Jul 2007, 12:47am |
|
|
 Asal me noor clinic waly pata nai keyon is cheez ko halal qarar deny ki poori koshish kar rahy hain. ye chee islam me b manah ha aur dosri baat ye k is se seht pe b side effect hoty hain. agar aap noor clinic k doctores nai manty to aisa karen k poora month aisa kar k dhekh le aap ko khud pata chal jaye gaa. aap log pata nai keyon logon ko ye yaqeen dilana chahty hain k ye sahi hai |
zain606 |
Group: Members Joined: 03rd May, 2007 Topic: 1 Post: 50 Age:
26
|
|
Posted on:12th Jul 2007, 2:57am |
|
|
Re: Mustttt Readdddddddddddd salam to all the people who brought this big issue here..Before saying anything i will request to all doctors that plss plsss show gr8 interest in this issue because its not a small issue. I think almost every second or third guyin pakistan is invovlved in mastrubation.
First of all i really appreciate the message in this problem that is right above me...yaar Our doctors say that Mastrubation is not bad for health because All western doctors and researchers say that. The very big issue that i want to bring here is the food and health...Upto some extent as a citizen of Canada i think People here and in US are 100 times healther than pakistani people and there food is lot more healthy than us. So they are more sexually active and if they mastrubate one day, they gain all the energy at the same day from their food. But its not the case in Pakistan because most of things are impure, even our flour is impure too so If western people say that mastrubation is not bad they say it because they did research on their own people..so i think it will be completely wrong to impliment the same rule for all the guys all over the world..right???
Yeahhhhhhhhhh one more thing. prepare to laugh..some how i never did mastrubation but to have an experiment i did it. Before saying more i just want to clear that my experiences are seperate from all other guys here. I will not force anything on other guys..OK Now listen.. After i did it My God is here i will not lie..i could not sleep untill 4 in morning and i felt really sever pain in my back on the same night..and when i got up at 12 ..look i had 8 hour sleep that is eneugh for healthy man but afer i wake up i was still feeling pain and was very tired...so i have done it i got experience and i will never do it again ...i did it to just have a medical proof wich became wrong in my case..i had read a lot of times in islamic books that "" Mastrubation is also Adultery(Zanaa)" but i did it for medical reasons and realised that Islam in More important than any Medical of this world...OK thaks for reading that Crap ...Allah Hafiz |
chunomuno |
Group: Members Joined: 24th Jun, 2007 Topic: 0 Post: 1 Age:
25
|
|
Posted on:12th Jul 2007, 8:04am |
|
|
Masturbation in Islam
Asalam-o-Alikum
inam_pk iam agree with u .. i think noor clinic ke Dr. ko ye link check karna chahiye .. shayud in ko in ki baato ka jawab mil jae .. kio ke ham in se behas nahi kar sukte bcoz we are not Alim... plz check this site http://islamicweb.com/resources/masturbation plz remove the space in this site
|
My Reply |
Group: Members Joined: 19th Sep, 2010 Topic: 2 Post: 2015 Age:
34
|
|
Posted on:13th Jul 2007, 2:28am |
|
|
re: chunumunohttp
1. ap ki batai hui site mai likha hai keh Imam shafai maslak ke mutabiq musht zani haram hai.
2. yahi bat noor clinic wale bhi kahte hai keh Imam shafai maslak ke tehat musht zani haram hai. yaqeen nahi aye tu khood dekh le: Masturbation and Islam
3. jab noor clinic wale bhi kahte hai keh shafai maslak ke tehat musht zani haram hai tu phir noor clinic se shikayat kaisi?
4. Koi cheez haram hai tu is ka yeh matlab kaise hua keh woh medically bhi nuqsan dah hai. musalmano ke lia pooja karna, cow ko god samajhna haram hai. is ka yeh matlab tu nahi keh pooja karne se ya cow ko god samajhne se medically koi nuqsan hai.
5. dunia bhar ke doctor is bat par muttafiq hai keh musht-zani se medically koi nuqsan nahi hota chahe woh kisi mazhab mai haram ho ya halal.
6. agar ap shafai maslak se taluq rakhte hai tu ap par lazim hai keh ap musht zani nahi kare. kio keh shafai maslak ke tehat yeh gunah hai.
7. lekin agar ap Imam hambal maslak se taluk rakhte hai tu ap musht-zani kar sakte hai kio keh Imam hambal maslak keh tehat musht-zani karne se koi gunah nahi hai.
|
inam_pk |
Group: Members Joined: 15th Jun, 2007 Topic: 2 Post: 8 Age:
33
|
|
Posted on:13th Jul 2007, 10:04pm |
|
|
 Doctors sahb aap ne ye nai bataya k Imam Abu Hanifa Razi Allah anho k nazdek mushtzani hilal ha ya haram. coz hum sab to Hanfi hain na. dosra aap ye nai manty k is ka koi nuqsan nai hai to is ka faida kia hai? aap kam az kam itna to man lee k Islam me ye sakhti se manah ha. ab plz is achy kaam ka koi aik faida b bata den. |
Kali Zuban |
Group: Members Joined: 19th Sep, 2010 Topic: 29 Post: 1793 Age:
27
|
|
Posted on:14th Jul 2007, 5:41am |
|
|
re: inam_pk
musht-zani aik bahut hi faida mand kam hai. kio keh musht-zani ke zaria insan apna mani kharij karta hai. jism se mani ka kharij karna etna hi zaroori hai jetna zaroori urine, stool kharij karna. mani kharij karne ka sahi tareeqa bivi ke sath mubasrat karna hai. lekin agar bivi na ho ya kisi aur city ya country mai ho tu phir doctor hazrat mashwarah dete hai keh masturbation ke zaria mani kharij karo. aur doctor hazrat 100% theek mashwarah dete hai. jo log doctor hazrat ke mashwarah par amal karna nahi chahte on ko chahia keh woh shadi kar ke bivi ke sath rahe aur bivi ke sath mubasrat kar ke mani kharij kare. lekin mani zaroor kharij kare. read: Musht Zani Nahi Karne Ke Nuqsanat
|
Pakspy |
Group: Members Joined: 23rd Jul, 2007 Topic: 0 Post: 7 Age:
27
|
|
Posted on:24th Jul 2007, 4:01am |
|
|
 Masturbation
The act of masturbation is prohibited in Islam, and must be avoided by the believers. But just to put it into perspective, the sin of masturbation is not as grave as the sin of zina (adultery or fornication). But it definitely is a sin, and an evil act, and must be avoided by the believers.
Allah says in the Holy Quran Chapter24 Surah Noor verse 30:O Prophet, enjoin the believing men to restrain their gaze, and guard their private parts. This is a more righteous way for them. Allah has knowledge of whatever they do.
Allah has commanded the believers to lower their gaze, and guard their chastity. This is a more righteous way for them. The act of zina (fornication or adultery) is a great sin in Islam. But the Prophet (saws) warned us against committing zina of the eyes, zina of the feet, zina of the hands, etc. If ones eyes are constantly watching sexual movies, magazines, etc. it would be considered zina of the eyes. If one goes to the place to commit zina or to the place of sexual movies, magazines, etc., it would be considered zina of the feet. Similarly, the act of masturbation, could be considered a zina of the eyes, or hands, etc. It is a sin and an evil act, and must be avoided by the believers.
It has been reported in an authentic narration, that the Messenger of Allah (saws) said, "O young people! Whoever among you can marry, should marry, because it helps him lower his gaze and guard his modesty; and whoever is not able to marry, should fast, as fasting diminishes his sexual power."
Thus if one is unable to control his sexual desire, he should get married, rather than get involved in committing sins like masterbation and zina (fornication or adultery). And if one is unable to marry, he should fast, as the Messenger of Allah (saws) says, that fasting reduces the persons sexual desire, and thus will stay away from committing sin.
Whatever written of Truth and benefit is only due to Allahs Assistance and Guidance, and whatever of error is of me. Allah Alone Knows Best and He is the Only Source of Strength.
|
|